MINUTES OF THE
JUNE 2007 TELECONFERENCE OF THE NATIONAL HYDROGEN AND FUEL CELLS CODES & STANDARDS COORDINATING COMMITTEE
MEETING DATE: June 6, 2007
MEETING TIME: 3:00 PM (ET)
MEETING PARTICIPANTS
A list of participants is shown in Attachment A.
1.0 Roll Call – Russ Hewett
Russ began the meeting by welcoming everyone and re-iterating that the Coordinating Committee is a collaborative activity of DOE, the National Hydrogen Association (NHA), the US Fuel Cell Council (USFCC) and NREL.
In the sprit of collaboration, the partners have agreed to rotate the facilitating of the monthly meetings. For June, it was NREL’s turn.
2.0 Reviewed Anti-Trust Guidelines – Robert Wichert, Sondra Ullman
Participants were asked to be mindful of the anti-trust guidelines:
Antitrust Guidelines (27Kb PDF)
and
Memo on Antitrust Guidelines (24Kb PDF)
3.0 Reviewed and approved the REVISED minutes of the May teleconference meeting.
No further corrections were necessary. Draft 3 was approved without any changes. Consequently, they will be posted on the NHA Hydrogen Safety Report website.
4.0 DOE Headquarters Update – Pat Davis / Antonio Ruiz
Antonio Ruiz reported on activities at DOE/HQ. Antonio thanks everyone for their participation in the DOE Hydrogen Program Annual Merit Review held during the period 15 - 18 May. He expects the report documenting the review and scores to be published in early September.
The DOE Hydrogen Program 2007 Annual Progress Report is expected to be out by about the time of the USFCC 2007 Fuel Cell Seminar, scheduled for October 15 - 19 in San Antonio, TX.
For FY07, full request appropriation made it possible for DOE to fund efforts that had to be curtailed in the past due to funding shortfalls. Work in hydrogen detection technology, such as sensors, has benefited from this increased funding.
For FY08, the Program is requesting $16.0 million, an increase of over $2.0. million from FY07. This will allow for continued sensor technology work and other R&D efforts.
5.0 California Hydrogen Motor Fuel Quality Standard – John Mough
John Mough provided an update. Dennis Johannes and Ed Williams and Roger Macy and Lorraine Casey and Gary Castro joined John Mough on the call.
The proposed draft specification and regulation for hydrogen fuel has been updated on the web site. A developmental fuel variance is also now included in the program. See http://www.cdfa.ca.gov/dms/hydrogenfuel/HydrogenFuel.htm for the details. Comments are being solicited through August 31st and should be provided to John Mough at jmough@cdfa.ca.gov . A 45 day comment period will follow. The requirement for a regulation by January 1, 2008 still stands.
Participating with John in the meeting, to assist John in providing the update, were the following persons from DMS:
- Dennis Johannes
- Ed Williams
- Roger Macy
- Lorraine Casey
6.0 California Hydrogen Motor Fuel Dispenser Standard – Gary Castro (John Mough)
Gary Castro and other staff members are reviewing information on this topic provided by Juana Williams. There is no mandated date of publication for additional standards.
Juana Williams' report (141Kb PDF)
Whether this draft will apply to gaseous hydrogen blends or not is not established yet.
There is no set deadline for adoption of this draft code. The work of the committee on this code is being made available to other stakeholders. The goal is to establish appropriate uniform standards for dispensers used to deliver hydrogen. The National Conference on Weights and Measures, Inc. is involved in these issues.
The process for developing a new code is as follows:
- A new code is introduced before the National Conference on Weights and Measures and the Conference votes on the code.
- If approved, NIST would publish the code in their publication handbooks.
- Once the handbook is published, the states would be able to adopt the handbook or portions of the handbook into state law and the states are responsible for enforcing the state laws.
The National Conference on Weights and Measures is also responsible for evaluating apparatus for measuring hydrogen based on these same codes, before the States accept these devices for use in commerce.
NIST is currently funded to work on developing hydrogen standards. A five year plan is being developed and will be made available to interested parties. The first project is to establish codes for metrology of hydrogen meters. A first draft has been distributed. A second draft based on comments will be issued shortly. A national working group is being developed, and industry experts are needed to participate. The working group will hold its first meeting in August or September to further develop the draft code. Quality standards may be incorporated into the codes. Safety practices will also be developed for sampling hydrogen products and inspection of hydrogen dispensers. Dispensers for gaseous and liquid dispensers will need to be addressed. In addition, hydrogen blends will need to be addressed.
The International Organization of Legal Metrology is also working on specifications for these devices. NIST is developing a U.S. position on these draft standards.
Education and promotion regarding the hydrogen economy within the weights and measures community is also being developed.
Field trials of the test procedures based on the codes that have been developed will follow the code development.
Training materials will need to be developed and subsequent training sessions will be held that include visits to field sites to demonstrate how hydrogen equipment operates and should be tested.
Inspection and test of higher pressure hydrogen systems (up to 10,000 psi) may be challenging since the prior experience at NIST is with CNG systems at lower pressures (3600 psi).
7.0 Report on Hydrogen Industry Panel on Codes (HIPOC) Activities – Darren Myers, Patrick Serfass, Tom Joseph, Carl Rivkin
Patrick Serfass reported on the ICC Final Action Hearings just completed. Many hydrogen proposals were submitted, mostly on the International Fire Code. Not all proposals were debated on the floor at the Final Action Hearings. Some were passed in a mass vote called the "consent agenda." The result of the current ICC cycle is to publish a supplement to the latest version of the model codes. Nine out of the fifteen proposals were approved and three of the remaining six were withdrawn. The others were disapproved by the ICC membership. The electrostatic discharge proposal was adopted to establish the required conductivity of the fueling pad. The language will apply to gasoline stations also. A technical problem with the units of resistivity was also flagged at the meeting and will be corrected. At the hearings, the HIPOC learned that since California has adopted the ICC Codes to take effect in 2008, there will be an increased presence of Californian permitting officials present at future hearings. It will be prudent, given their interest in hydrogen and level of activity in the state, to make sure future proposals are vetted with them so future issues can be addressed in a timely manner.
NFPA 52 and NFPA 55 comments and proposals were submitted recently. The comment period just closed on May 25.
The next open meeting of the HIPOC is as follows:
HIPOC Meeting REVISED DATE June 12th, 2007
Date: 06/12/2007
Start Time: 11:00 AM US/Eastern
Duration: 90 minutes
Presenter: Tom Joseph, HIPOC Chair
8.0 NNFPA Activities: NFPA 2 – Carl Rivkin, Marty Gresho
The annual NFPA meeting is just closing up. A consent document was filed on NFPA 30A to add some requirements for hydrogen referencing NFPA 52. This effectively ties NFPA 30A and NFPA 52 together for hydrogen fuels. The proposal closing date for NFPA 52 and 55 was May 25. Several hundred proposals were received for each. A meeting in June will discuss these issues.
The hydrogen siting project results were presented by Hughes at the NFPA meeting.
The technical committee for NFPA 2 is in the midst of their work. Regular meetings are being held. The full NFPA 2 Committee will meet this fall. The target publication date is fall of 2009.
The meeting dates are as follows:
- NFPA 55 / (Industrial and Medical Gases Technical Committee): June 26-28, 2007 Cincinnati, OH (3 full days)
- NFPA 52/ (Vehicular Alternative Fuel Systems Technical Committee): July 17-19, 2007 Redondo Beach, CA (3 full days)
- NFPA 2 / (Hydrogen Technology Technical Committee): October 23-25, 2007 Oakland Bay area (3 full days)
9.0 IEC TC 105 – Kelvin Hecht
Kelvin Hecht's report (82Kb PDF)
10.0 ISO TC 197 – Debbie Angerman
Debbi Angerman's report (81Kb PDF)
13.0 Other Code Developing Organization and Standards Developing Organization Updates
No reports
14.0 Next Meeting
Theoretically, the next meeting would be a Teleconference Meeting on July 4th. Due to the holiday, the meeting will be held on July 5th.
Teleconference Meeting on July 5th
3:00 PM US Eastern Time
Call In Number: +1 641 594 7000
PIN: 824011#
ATTACHMENT A: PARTICIPANTS IN THE MAY 2007 TELECONFERENCE MEETING OF THE NATIONAL HYDROGEN AND FUEL CELLS CODES & STANDARDS COORDINATING COMMITTEE
| NAME |
ORGANIZATION |
PRESENT
AT MEETING
(Yes/No) |
| Adam Gromis |
California Fuel Cell Partnership |
|
| Andrei Tchouvelev |
A. V. Tchouvelev & Associates, Inc. |
|
| Anna Stukas |
Angstrom Power |
Yes |
| Antonio Ruiz |
USDOE/Hydrogen, Fuel Cell and Infrastructure Technologies Program |
Yes |
| Bill Chernicoff |
USDOT/Research and Innovative Technologies Administration(RITA)/Washington |
|
| Bill Collins |
UTC Fuel Cells |
|
| Bill Hoagland |
Hoagland and Associates |
|
| Brad Smith |
Shell Hydrogen |
|
| Carl Rivkin |
National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) |
Yes |
| Carolyn Elam |
DOE Golden Field Office |
|
| Cathy Gregoire-Padro |
Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL) |
|
| Chris Sloane |
General Motors |
|
| Christina Zhang-Tillman |
California Fuel Cell Partnership |
|
| Christopher Moen |
Sandia National Laboratories/Livermore |
|
| Dan Casey |
ChevronTexaco |
Yes |
| Darren Meyers |
International Code Council (ICC) |
|
| David McClosky |
USDOC/NIST |
|
| Debbie Angerman |
Compressed Gas Association (CGA) |
|
| Doug Horne |
Clean Vehicle Education Foundation |
Yes |
| Gary Nakarada |
Regulatory Logic |
Yes |
| Glen Schleffler |
Consultant to NREL |
|
| Greg Milewski |
Shell Oil Products |
|
| Hank Seiff |
Clean Vehicle Education Foundation |
|
| Holly Thomas |
|
Yes |
| Jacquelyn Birdsall |
|
Yes |
| Jesse Schneider |
DaimlerChrysler |
|
| Jim McGetrick |
BP |
|
| John Koehr |
American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) |
|
| John Mough |
California Division of Measurement Standards |
Yes
|
| Jonathan Muntez |
U.S. DOE |
Yes |
| Jonathan Otero |
BP |
Yes |
| Juana Williams |
NIST |
Yes |
| Julie Cairns |
CSA America |
|
| Karen Hall |
National Hydrogen Association (NHA) |
|
| Kelvin Hecht |
ANSI, IEC and Consultant to NREL |
Yes |
| Ken Krastins |
Plug Power |
Yes |
| Larry Moulthrop |
Proton Energy Systems |
Yes |
| Laurie Florence |
Underwriter Laboratories |
|
| Lesley Crowell |
California Air Resources Board |
|
| Mark Richards |
Versa Power Systems |
|
| Michael Sprague |
Enersol, Inc. |
|
| Michael Steele |
General Motors Advanced Technology Vehicles |
Yes |
| Nha Nguyen |
NHTSA/Office of International Policy and Harmonization |
|
| Nick Burkhead |
Shell Hydrogen |
|
| Pat Davis |
USDOE/Hydrogen, Fuel Cell and Infrastructure Technologies Program |
|
| Patrick Flynn |
Enersol, Inc. |
|
| Patrick Serfass |
National Hydrogen Association (NHA) |
Yes |
| Paul Bouchard |
Energy Conversion Devices |
Yes |
| Paul Buehler |
Plug Power, Inc. |
Yes |
| Prentiss Searles |
American Petroleum Institute (API) |
Yes |
| Robert Wichert |
US Fuel Cell Council (USFCC) |
Yes |
| Rhoads Stephenson |
Motor Vehicle Fire Research Institute |
Yes |
| Roger Smith |
Compressed Gas Association (CGA) |
|
| Ron Coiner |
CSA America |
|
| Sam Sprik |
National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) |
|
| Samuel Lam |
British Columbia Ministry of Transportation |
Yes |
| Sheral Arbuckle |
Ford Motor Company |
|
| Sondra Ullman |
Plug Power |
Yes |
| Terry Conrad |
Concurrent Technologies Corp. |
|
| Thad Adams |
Savannah River National Laboratory |
|
| Tom Joseph |
Air Products and Chemicals |
|
| Tony Androsky |
US Fuel Cell Council (USFCC) |
|
| Jim Ohi |
National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) |
|
| Russ Hewett |
National Renewable Energy Laboratory |
Yes |
Guests
Ben Deal (California Air Resources Board) – subbing for Leslie Crowell
Harry Jones (Underwriter Laboratories) – subbing for Laurie Florence
Gary Castro (California Department of Food and Agriculture/Division of Measurement Standard)
Dennis Johannes (California Department of Food and Agriculture/Division of Measurement Standard)
Ed Williams (California Department of Food and Agriculture/Division of Measurement Standard)
Roger Macy (California Department of Food and Agriculture/Division of Measurement Standard)
Lorraine Casey (California Department of Food and Agriculture/Division of Measurement Standard)
|