You are here: Archives > December 2005 > First Responders Get H2 Safety Training

First Responders Get Hydrogen Car Safety Facts in Torrance
Muhammed El-Hasan
Reprinted from Daily Breeze.com



As the auto industry races ahead with technology to run vehicles on hydrogen gas, what happens when one of these cars rolls on the road?

Will the vehicle explode like the hydrogen-filled Hindenburg in 1937?
What will emergency responders such as firefighters do at the scene?
A conference Wednesday in Torrance brought about 200 emergency responders, building safety personnel, public officials and others from across the state to discuss hydrogen car safety.

"Hydrogen is not the threat or terror people associate with it when they think of the Hindenburg," said Ruben Grijalva, California state fire marshal, who delivered the keynote speech. "A key thing here is identifying what are the public safety issues, and that includes getting rid of the myths."

For example, if hydrogen escapes from a vehicle tank, the gas usually disappears into the atmosphere in a harmless manner. However, gasoline tends to pool on the ground, posing a fire risk, Grijalva said.

The Los Angeles Area Fire Marshals Association and the California Fuel Cell Partnership organized the event to help acquaint fire departments and other safety organizations with risks and challenges of hydrogen-powered vehicles.

Automakers including Toyota, Honda and Nissan -- which have U.S. or North American headquarters in the South Bay -- are years, if not decades, from selling hydrogen-powered vehicles to the public.

Prototypes already are running on American roads, mostly in California. The vehicles use a fuel cell to combine hydrogen gas from a tank with oxygen from the air to produce electricity to run a vehicle motor. The byproducts are water and heat.

New state fire and building codes are adopted every three years, while the technology behind hydrogen-run vehicles and refueling stations advances much quicker. As a result, the codes lag the technology, Grijalva said.

So emergency responders must be "flexible" as they deal with an incident such as a vehicle rollover involving hydrogen, he said.
For example, there's no industry standard for the location of hydrogen tanks or high-voltage wire in a fuel cell vehicle. He stressed greater communication between automakers, local agencies, developers of safety codes and emergency responders to help deal with ambiguities in the code.

That means local agencies must report any incidents involving hydrogen to emergency responders, he said.

"We don't want our codes to be based on what-ifs," Grijalva said. "We want to have real-world examples."

During a panel discussion, a Toyota official said that his company's hydrogen-powered prototype has adequate safety precautions.
For example, if "anything goes wrong," the car's high voltage is isolated inside the two metal cases, said Gary Smith, Toyota's national service technology manager.

"I can assure you these vehicles are safe," said Smith.
In Honda's hydrogen-powered vehicle prototype, the high-voltage system is "completely isolated" from the car's frame to prevent the chance of an electric shock from just touching, say, the hood, said Ryan Harty, a Honda vehicle test engineer.

Steve Hoffman, an official at Air Products and Chemicals Inc., which is working with Shell Hydrogen to open hydrogen refueling stations, summed up the sentiment of the speakers.

"Hydrogen is not more or less safe than other fuels," Hoffman said. "It's just different."